RISING STAR ! The ultimate source to ace your NYPD Sergeant, Lieutenant, and Captain Exam Visit www.RisingStarPromotion.com to subscribe to our mailing list and get info on the next Sgt, Lt. or Captain Exam!

I was told 106 was rejected as a throwout....I will see how accurate that is in a few weeks...but if true..then it will prob be low throwout numbers

I don't think 9 is the number nor will all of those numbers be changed. The longer it drags out The more hope I lose with the number of changes.

Cims was 78

just wondering anyone know the reason 106 would be good ?

7 in my opinion will be a change if not throwout...

Don't remember the question just a couple of people who protested it as a throwout. If not a throwout and it's a change what you think would be the double/triple ?

I heard it was good because the Ts guy was on meal not sure what to think

Don't think anything was wrong with the Cims question.

But 45 should definitely be a throw out.

Just my opinion. In the end dcas will do what dcas wants to do.

Jabronijoe29 wrote:

---

How is 106 not a throwout... The correct answer as per dcas was after the cutoff date clearly

---

Agreed, I got 106 correct because I got lucky, but if 106 isn't a throwout then nothing was a throwout. That was hands down, 100% wrong according to the cutoff date.

I don't think anything is written in stone with dcas. The ops orders and ccrg were not on the noe but they look like their sticking.
In the end what is our recourse if we feel wronged or cheated by dcas? Lawsuit, media attention, crying? Nothing will change what they decide to do.

Amen! 19 changes submitted...I think 5 to 19 changes are in play..I expect to see 5

If that's the case, we are looking at minimum changes

Capt went down there

Ok thanks everyone..I guess the only thing we can do is continue waiting

wisecop wrote:

---

sgt2be wrote:

---

Amen! 19 changes submitted...I think 5 to 19 changes are in play..I expect to see 5

---

 I agree with sgt2be, the majority coming out the inbasket and at least two on the rest of the test.

-- Edited by wisecop on Friday 8th of January 2016 11:30:08 PM

---

 Put it this way, if there are people with political connections that scored 60 or better and an entity is pushing a certain person or persons which happens all the time in civil service then we're looking at signifcant amount of changes. If none of that is going on, most are taking this test again in early 2017.

 

The Choas theory or butterly effect is what all of us are experiencing.  Small causes having large effects. Captain Pony tail has altered the lives of many sergeants who should have passed under fair conditions and now it boils down to pure luck for many.

-- Edited by Cathetel on Saturday 9th of January 2016 12:00:18 AM

-- Edited by Cathetel on Saturday 9th of January 2016 12:06:35 AM

-- Edited by Cathetel on Saturday 9th of January 2016 12:09:22 AM

I think we will all be surprised with this list's outcome ,...the wait is almost over.

I dont..I have heard from 2 good sources that number 1 is throwout....I also heard 7 was being talked about as possible throwout....those are the only 2 I heard...106 I was told no throwout based on it was most correct

Yes it was the most correct answer...even though it was not all correct

I did not protest these....I don't think 106 will be changed...I do think 1 will be throwout...those are the ones I'm pretty confident about. Again this process is so secret it's hard to ever be sure of anything

6th month....I'd have to look at it again...I believe if I remember correct the other choices wrre all things the wrong actor was supposed to do...meaning if they wrre asking about patrol supervisor then those other choices dealt w first supervisor on scene

U may be right. But the puzzle of this is that it could go either way. Absolutely could. It's not even wishful thinking it's just the fact that dcas is a mystery in itself. We might see a really small list which yes means another exam coming up. I would guess late 2017 bc they ll have more newly promoted sgts meaning more exam takers. Or, we could have a repeat of 2011. The ones they threw out there weren't dead on convincing to s. U just never know---with this it's anyone's guess. It's very hush hush this guy has dropped log after log on this exam as well----that doesn't help the flow.

Cathetel wrote:

---

The Choas theory or butterly effect is what all of us are experiencing.  Small causes having large effects. Captain Pony tail has altered the lives of many sergeants who should have passed under fair conditions and now it boils down to pure luck for many.

---

 I agree with your post but the butterfly effect is when an even infinitely small variations creates huge changes to a system.  This was not that. This was a fundamental variation.  This guy is not a butterfly. He is Mothra!!!  I've heard a lot of war stories about Capt V since this started.  It doesn't matter if the person was a subordinate, colleague or supervisor, they all say everything this guy touches is a complete **** show.  I'm more annoyed at the people on this job who put this idiot in a position to have such a profound, negative affect on so many careers.   He shouldnt be a duty capt or shoe fly for the same reason.  The extent of this guy's responsibilities shouldn't exceed polishing spent shell casings  in an isolated, unheated trailer at Rodman's Neck!

ondeeair2321 wrote:

---

U may be right. But the puzzle of this is that it could go either way. Absolutely could. It's not even wishful thinking it's just the fact that dcas is a mystery in itself. We might see a really small list which yes means another exam coming up. I would guess late 2017 bc they ll have more newly promoted sgts meaning more exam takers. Or, we could have a repeat of 2011. The ones they threw out there weren't dead on convincing to s. U just never know---with this it's anyone's guess. It's very hush hush this guy has dropped log after log on this exam as well----that doesn't help the flow.

---

 Explain how the guy dropped log after log about the exam... he wrote this piece of garbage exam.. what logs is he dropping?

bigfoot45 wrote:

---

Bigguy69 wrote:

---

Dcas is playing hardball, even with this small list. A lot of us including myself were expecting a throw out bonanza. I'm shaking in my boots with a 69.. 67 and below your toast .

---

So if I read between the lines here, it sounds like 2 or 3 changes.

---

 I say 19, i dont see them straying too far from what the tvb recommended....they never have in the past.